It won’t take six conservative justices to undo Gorsuch’s majority opinion, only five – and we all know the likelihood that whoever wins the presidential election will be able to appoint at least two new justices before 2025.
About nine months ago I stated that Justices Thomas, Alito, Gorsuch, and Kavanaugh are capable of concocting an anti-transgender opinion that would non-hyperbolically be compared to Dred Scott v. Sandford.
“If every single living American had been surveyed in 1964,” Justice Samuel Alito opined in Harris/Bostock/Zarda on Monday, “it would have been hard to find any who thought that discrimination because of sex meant discrimination because of sexual orientation––not to mention gender identity, a concept that was essentially unknown at the time.”
Not quite as disgusting as Chief Justice Roger Taney’s flippant musing that wrote non-white Africans and their descendants out of the Constitution in Dred Scott, but it would have been enough to end trans people’s relationship with federal civil rights law (if not more) had Alito been joined by more than Justice Clarence Thomas.
Alito declared that “any” notion that the term “because of sex” could have had anything to do with sexual orientation or gender identity “would have clashed in spectacular fashion with the societal norms of the day.”
Alito also boldly asserted that “there is not a shred of evidence” that any Member of Congress would have interpreted the statutory “sex” to include anti-LGB or anti-T discrimination when Title VII was enacted.
How about Robert McClory? He was a Republican who served in the Illinois Senate from 1953 to 1963. In 1955 he voted in favor of S.B. 569, the bill that would become the first incarnation of the state’s trans birth certificate statute. Six years later he voted for H.B. 654, a bill that re-enacted the state’s vital statistics code – including the 1955 trans language.
How about Robert McLoskey, another Republican. He served in the Illinois House during the same period. He also voted for S.B. 569 in 1955 and he also voted for H.B. 654 in 1961.
Even if you disagree with the notion of ascribing pro-civil rights intent to votes for trans birth certificate statutes, each of these men nevertheless was presented with two opportunities to evaluate trans existence to some degree.
By 1964, both men were serving in the U.S. House of Representatives. There, each had two opportunities to vote on the Civil Rights Act of 1964 – first in February and then again in July.
Each time, each one voted yes.
Make no mistake, that does not mean that, via TARDIS or any other time travel conveyance, had one been able to interview either man immediately after their votes on the Civil Rights Act bill they would have clearly articulated a pro-trans spin on those votes. In fact, I’d say the odds would be against it.
“While Americans in 1964 would have been shocked to learn that Congress had enacted a law prohibiting sexual orientation discrimination, they would have been bewildered to hear that this law also forbids discrimination on the basis of ‘transgender status’ or ‘gender identity,’ terms that would have left people at the time scratching their heads.”
The linkage between the two Roberts, the two trans birth certificate bills, and the two Civil Rights Act votes destroys Alito’s (and co-signatory Thomas’s) faux-historical faux-reasoning.
Those two members of Congress did indeed have some idea about both concepts – “sex” and “change of sex” – even if only subconsciously. Their votes prove that assertion in a way that neither all the GOP’s Supreme Court Justices nor all of the GOP Justices’ law clerks nor all of the dark money-funded right-wing think tanks can ever refute. But Alito’s opinion demonstrates yet again the inherent inability of a wide swath of legal and historical professionals to grasp that trans issues received some favorable legal treatment as early as the Eisenhower Era.
“It defies belief,” Alito can utter as often as he wants, “to suggest that the public meaning of discrimination because of sex in 1964 encompassed discrimination on the basis of a concept that was essentially unknown to the public at that time.”
Enactments of the Illinois Legislature are not suggestions; they’re laws.
If Alito’s opinion in Harris/Bostick/Zarda had been the majority, there would be ample cause to dissect its fifty pages of appendices, bursting at the seams with dictionary definitions of “sex.”
Nevertheless, here’s a suggestion for Justice Alito: When next you find yourself in an encounter with law enforcement authorities who might be leaning toward prosecuting you – for what? Who knows.
But in such an encounter, try telling officials, “Sorry, I have my dictionary, and its definition trumps the wording of the law you’re trying to enforce.”
I think we all know how that will go.
And so, Alito and Thomas (and in a separate opinion, Brett Kavanaugh) were not part of a majority.
Lead authorship of the majority opinion fell to Neil Gorsuch, who, following oral arguments, a few bold folks predicted might rule as he ultimately did because of his penchant for textualism.
I wasn’t one of those.
As recently as Monday morning, I thought the best outcome we could hope for would be a 4-1-4 split with the liberals writing passionately for LGBTQ people and today’s three dissenters (together with Gorsuch, still savoring Merrick Garland’s seat) viciously attacking us, with Chief Justice Roberts penning a narrow opinion against us that would deprive us of our rights without having neo-Dred Scott-ism actually carrying the day as a majority holding of the court.
I was wrong. And I’m glad.
But I’m also worried.
Some cheering is warranted, but not as much as I’ve been seeing. Do not trust anyone who says that we no longer need “sexual orientation” and “gender identity” to be hardwired into federal anti-discrimination law.
It won’t take six conservative justices to undo Gorsuch’s majority opinion, only five – and I think we all know what the likelihood is that whoever wins the presidential election in November will be able to appoint at least two new Supreme Court justices before 2025.
Complacency has dealt near-deathblows to the community more than once. One more might finally do the trick.
Check out the original story here: LGBTQ Nation.
Have you found the right one, or are you still searching?
Join a gay dating site where you can meet single guys from any town or city. Rely instead on Gay Dating Solutions to do the work for you! Don’t get fooled by free offers made by other sites. Gay Dating Solutions is offering a FREE 6 month promotion ABSOLUTELY no strings, request for credit card numbers, etc…it is the only site that is truly free to join!
Sign-up now: www.gaydatingsolutions.com
Download our mobile apps: https://appurl.io/jd0jaqp0
Like us on Facebook: www.facebook.com/GayDating101
Tweet us: twitter.com/GayDating101
Tags: #BigBankChallenge #BohemianKissChallenge #EqualityActJapan #StopAsianHate 12 Dates of Christmas 2020 Olympics Aaron Schock Adam Castillejo Adam Rippon addiction ageism Aging AhTave AIDS Aime Wichtendal Alaska Alex Morse Almost Love America's Next Top Model American Medical Association Amy Coney Barrett Annise Parker Antes Que El Mundo Se Acabe Anti-Asian Violence Anti-LGBTQ ANTM anxiety Aptima HIV-1 Arizona Armie Hammer astrology At-home date Atlanta Atlanta Black Pride Atlanta GA Atlanta Nightlife Atlanta Pride Atlanta Pride Run Atlanta’s Queer History Bicycle Tour Austin Swink Austin Texas Austin TX Backpacks for the Street Basel Abou Hamrah BFI Flare Bisexual BLACK GAY MEN Black LGBTQ Atlanta Black Lives Matter Black Love Bohemian Rhapsody Boston Boston MA Boston Nightlife Brian Sims Broadway bully Bullying California Call Me By Your Name Canada Capital Pride Capitalism Cason Crane Celebrity News censorship Chemistry Chemsex Chicago Chicago IL Chris Evans Christian proselytizing Christianity Christmas Christmas commercial Christmas movie Christmas Movies Chucky Circus of Books civil unions Cody McCook Colorado Comedy coming out commentary compatibility Confidence Congress conspiracy theory Conversion therapy CoronaVirus Court Vox COVID COVID-19 Covid-19 vaccine Cubbyhole NYC daddy Dallas Dallas Gay Bars Dallas Gayborhood Dallas Texas Danica Roem Daniel Harding Daniel Howell Date night dating dating advice Dating Apps Dating Red Flags dating rut dating tips DC Pride Dead to Me Denver Depression discrimination Disney Documentary Dolf Pasker Dolly Parton Domestic Violence Donald Trump Donna Price Drag Race drag racing Dustin Lance Black election Election 2020 Election Day Elite Employment Entertainment Entertainment news epidemic Fabio Fasoli Family family gatherings Film Finding True Love First Date First Date Etiquette first date ideas first date tips Flirting Tips Flirty Dancing Florida Fort Lauderdale Franklin Graham Freddie Mercury Garrett Clayton gay gay asian gay asian men Gay Atlanta Gay Austin Gay Bars NYC Gay beaches Gay Boston Gay Boston Nightlife Gay Chicago Gay Christmas Gay Couple Gay Couples Gay Culture Gay Dallas Gay Dallas Nightlife gay dating gay dating advice gay dating app gay dating apps Gay Dating Red Flags Gay Dating Solutions Gay Dating Tips Gay DC gay discrimination gay film Gay Florida Gay Fort Lauderdale Gay Health Gay Holiday Movie Gay Houston gay kiss Gay Love Advice gay marriage gay marriage proposal gay men Gay Miami gay midlife Gay Mountaineer Gay Movies Gay New York Gay nightlife Gay Nurse Gay NYC Gay Panic Gay Pride gay relationship advice gay relationship tips gay relationships Gay Santa Gay Scene gay seniors gay sex gay singles Gay Soldier Gay Travel Gay Twitter Gay Washington DC Gay Wedding gay weddings Gay Widower Gays Over COVID gaysian Gen Z Generation Z Georgia Gert Kasteel Ghosting GLAAD GOP Gorsuch Greater Houston LGBTQ Chamber of Commerce grindr Guy Vandenberg Gym Gays Haaz Sleiman Hallmark Halloween Hate Crime HBO Max Health HGVT HIV HIV prevention HIV stigma HIV treatment HIV vaccine HIV/AIDS hobbies Holi-date Holiday Film Holiday Movies Holidays Hollywood Holyoke Homophobia hooking up hookup hookup culture Hot Vax Summer House Hunters Houston Houston Texas Houston TX Hulu Ian Jordan Indya Moore Instagay Instagram intersex Intimacy Intimacy coach Iowa Iowa caucus isolation It's A Sin Jake Gyllenhaal James Bushe Japan Jaymes Vaughan Jayson Conner Jeffrey Newman Jennifer Tilly Jewish Jewish persecution Joe Biden Jonathan Bennett Josef Salvat Jussi-Pekka Kajaala Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg JVN Jwan Yosef Karamo Brown Kristine Stolakis Lady Gaga Lesbian lesbian couple Let It Snow LGBT LGBT Austin LGBT Travel Guide LGBT-Free Zones LGBTQ LGBTQ Asians LGBTQ Atlanta LGBTQ Austin LGBTQ Boston LGBTQ Chicago LGBTQ Dallas LGBTQ DC LGBTQ discrimination LGBTQ employees LGBTQ Family LGBTQ Film LGBTQ Film Festival LGBTQ Films LGBTQ flag LGBTQ Fort Lauderdale LGBTQ Health LGBTQ History LGBTQ Houston LGBTQ Miami LGBTQ movies LGBTQ New York LGBTQ nightlife LGBTQ NYC LGBTQ Pride LGBTQ retirees LGBTQ retirement LGBTQ Rights LGBTQ Seniors LGBTQ Victory Institute LGBTQ Youth Life Lifetime Lifetime TV Network Linda Warren lockdown London LGBTIQ+ Film Festival loneliness Love Victor Love Wins Luke Evans Male Nurse Malik Brown marriage equality marriage proposal Marsha P Johnson Marvel Marvin Cortes Massachusetts mature gay dating mental health Mexico Miami Miami Beach Miami Beach Pride Miami Florida Miami nightlife Michael Cashman Michael Henry Middle-aged gay men midlife Modern Family mormon Mr. Right Muscle gays music video My Gay Match NASCAR National Coming Out Day Nationwide Conversion Therapy Ban Neil Gorsuch Netflix Netflix Special Nevada New Year's Resolution New York New York City Nonbinary North Dakota Northern Ute tribe Norway Nurse Appreciation Week NYC NYC Events NYC Pride NYC Pride 2021 Oak Lawn Obergefell v. Hodges older gay man Omander Omar Ayuso One True Pairing online dating online dating apps online dating tips online gay dating Online trolls Open Relationship Operation Hyacinth OTP Outfest Outfest LA 2021 Outfest Los Angeles Pan-African Pride pandemic Paper Moons Pat Robertson Pennsylvania Perez Hilton personality Personality Matching personality type Pete Buttigieg Pink Capitalism Poland Politics polyamorous polyamorous relationship polyamorous relationships Pope Francis Pose power bottom Pray Away PrEP pride Pride 2021 Pride Afrique Pride Flag Pride Month Prince Harry profile pic Puerto Vallarta quarantine Queer eye Queer Film Queer Films Queer Holiday Movies Queer Lawmakers Queer Love Story Queer Santa Queer Youth racism Rafa Olarra Rainbow Wave red flags Reddit Relationship relationship advice Relationship Tips relationships religion Rep. Andy Biggs Republican retirement Ricky Martin rom-com Romantic Comedy Ryan Murphy Ryan O’Connell Samaritan’s Purse same sex marriage Same Sex Relationships Same Sex Wedding Same-Sex Couples Same-Sex Kiss same-sex marriage same-sex marriage ban Santa Claus Schitt’s Creek Score Miami Score Nightclub Scott Evans Scott Wiener Section 28 self isolation self-care Senior Gay Dating Senior Gay Men senior gays Senior Prom Seven Summits sex Sex and Intimacy Sex Education sex life sexual identity sexual preference sexual racism sexuality short film Shy Gay Guys Single All the Way single gay man Single Gay Men Single Gays Single Young Gays social distancing social isolation social media Social Security Somerville South Florida sports Stonewall Stonewall Riots straight men Super Bowl ads Super Bowl commercials Super Bowl LIV Supreme Court Switzerland Syfy Syria Tan France Television Tennessee The Boys in the Band The Center on Colfax The Christmas Setup The Eternals The First The Thing About Harry Threesome throuple TikTok Tom Daley toxic gay relationship toxic masculinity toxic relationships Transgender Travel Travis Shumake true love Trump administration Turner Free TV series Tweets Twitter Unconditional Love United Methodist Church US economy US Supreme Court Valentine's day viral news viral video Virginia Washington DC Web Series Wedding When Harry met Santa Workplace workplace discrimination World AIDS Day World Pride Young Gay Guys young gay men Youth YouTube